Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Nice or Not

who's talking here?

Just another girl 1
chica 1
peachyme 3
Kathryn 6
banana4 1
Girlie Girl 1
Master Procrastinator 8
Sam 2
3IML 1
Jennifer 1
LizzyB 2
MaryVon 1
Caitlin 4
Hmmm 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Nice or Not

My little brother, who I have not talked to in 5 years calls me out of the blue today. He doesn't apologize for our falling out, he just explains his finances and asks me for $2000. It is a bad situation and he does have kids. Should I be a doormat and "loan" him money? ("loan" is a loose term. I'll probably never get it back.)

Yes, he's family Vote
 
 8.7% (2)
No, f*ck him Vote
 
 60.9% (14)
You should consider it. Vote
 
 30.4% (7)
Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

My little brother, who I have not talked to in 5 years calls me out of the blue today. He doesn't apologize for our falling out, he just explains his finances and asks me for $2000. It is a bad situation and he does have kids. Should I be a doormat and "loan" him money? ("loan" is a loose term. I'll probably never get it back.) 

Caitlin --- 17 years ago -

i would but thats just me 

peachyme --- 17 years ago -

I was adopted and the first time I talked to my birth sister she asked for money. I hate when people do that but its really all on your opinion of the situation. Every situation is different. 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

Nope, he's a big boy I'm assuming since he has kids. After not talking for that long, its almost like asking a stranger for money. 

Just another girl --- 17 years ago -

id personally say no because he didnt have time to contact you in the 5 years but he has time to contact you when he needs something. 

Jennifer --- 17 years ago -

I absolutely WOULD NOT! I have a brother who does the same thing, you don't want to open that can of worms! I would say, if there is something that the kids are in need of (clothes or something?) buy it and ship it. I would help my nephews out at a drop of a hat.... but I buy them what they need, I never send money to their parents. That's what I do anyways... 

banana4 --- 17 years ago -

Honestly, I know there are kids involved..but can he not get a loan? Or even one of those incredibly crappy paycheck loan places (that charge way too much interest fyi) It's hard when there's kids involved, but I'd say no unless he's exhausted all his real options. 5 years is a long time then to just call someone out of the blue without a real conversation. 

peachyme --- 17 years ago -

I agree with Jennifer. If I did do something I would buy it rather then give them money to buy it. 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

It's for land tax 

chica --- 17 years ago -

I would definitely offer to buy something they need but I would not loan money after 5 years of not speaking... 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

No..offer to buy diapers or milk, or food. but the amount of money he wants no. 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

If he can't afford the land tax, he shouldn't be living on it. Get himself an apartment with room for the kiddos. Bad blood between you two was already there, so if you say no to the money, what more bad blood could you create? He got your number/email address from a family member didn't he...I wonder how many others he asked before you. 

Caitlin --- 17 years ago -

do u have someone back home where he is that you trust that u can wire some money so that they can go buy what he needs? that way he doesnt spend it on something else 

LizzyB --- 17 years ago -

I was adopted and the first time I talked to my birth sister she asked for money. ME TO!!!!! 

LizzyB --- 17 years ago -

I'm on board with Caitlin and Kathryn. Order what he needs online and have it shipped to him :). 

3IML --- 17 years ago -

It depends on why he can't afford it, my brother in law always asks us for $$$ and I won't give him any because he's a drunk. 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

He's a drunk and a recovering meth addict. 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

There is your answer...a big NO NO NO. Those poor kids, anyone that can take them somewhere better while he gets his crap together? 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

In his favor, he has been clean for probably 9 months and he's married and his wife is clean now too. They have two small children and he works full time. He does still drink like a fish though. I dont' know. I have zero respect for that bunch. if you're on my myspace, go read my new blog. It tells more detail regarding the situation. I almost feel like I should. I dunno. 

Hmmm --- 17 years ago -

he is a grown a$$ man if he got himself in to the mess, he should be grown enough to get his self out of it. 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

If you do something "nice" for anyone, always do it first for you. You will have to live with your regrets. If you do not help and they lose their home or something, will you be okay with that? If you do help and your brother chooses to not speak to you again, will you be okay with that? You know? 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

If you do something "nice" for anyone, always do it first for you. You will have to live with your regrets. If you do not help and they lose their home or something, will you be okay with that? If you do help and your brother chooses to not speak to you again, will you be okay with that? You know Well, I haven't talked to him in 5 years. It won't bother me if I never talk to him again and technically, it wouldn't be my fault if he loses his home. It would be his fault. 

Caitlin --- 17 years ago -

If this was my brother, and its not so I dont know how you are feeling, but if it was I would order what he needs for his children online. OR, I would find someone who I know very very well and trust to hold a certain amount of money, find out what he needs and then go buy it for him. You DO NOT want to give him a chance to buy more meth or spend it on more booze. I dont know exactly WHAT he needs but if its clothes for the kiddos, you can order that with no problem. What do they need? 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

Well, I haven't talked to him in 5 years. It won't bother me if I never talk to him again and technically, it wouldn't be my fault if he loses his home. It would be his fault. That's how I see it, too. So do what you can live with best. We've helped out family before and have both regretted it and felt really good about it. I don't think you can ever tell sometimes. 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

No, he has to pay his land tax that he's deliquent on. It's 5 years past due and its going into foreclosure. 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

Oh, and this is not the first time I gave him money. Back when we were talking still, I loaned him a total of $500 but never got paid back one penny. He was on drugs then though and I was blissfully unaware. 

Master Procrastinator --- 17 years ago -

The more I'm talking this out, the more I'm realizing he can f*ck off. Yeah....that fixes that. Thanks guys! lol 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

5 Years was plenty of time to not be deliquent...Judge Judy would have a few choice words for him I bet! I just read your blog, and yeah, that was the crappiest conversation ever. You are not his sister anymore, he is not your responsibility. Oh, and we've have had to tell a family member NO before many times after my dads family found out what this family member was using the money for. He had a kid, and a wife, and his love of drugs. He is now homeless, kid is living with a trusted family member, and we never liked the wife at all (also addict). He has dropped off the face of the planet. 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

^wrote as conclusion was coming from MP. 

Girlie Girl --- 17 years ago -

Okay um yeah...I just read your blog too...and I say no way. PERIOD. It's a very sad situation but they made their "choice" 5 years ago. Good luck girl. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground