Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Should she have gotten jail time?

who's talking here?

mwr885 6
SemperFiChic 1
Sara 1
lilloudymouth 2
*shenanigans* 2
cayetx 5
Julie 1
Troublemaker 2
AJ :) 10
ChiTownGrl 1
InYoFace 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

Ok so i had a very close friend all through middle school. We grew apart and didnt talk much when we got to high school. At 16 she got pregnant and didnt tell anyone. Her mother said she was not pregnant when my mom asked(they were and are good friends) I could tell she was so i have no idea how her mother couldnt. Anyways on Christmas eve, she had the baby in the bathroom at her home. She didnt tell anyone she was going into labor. Finally her mother found her and called 911. By the time they arrived the baby was dead. They were debating about giving her jail time but somehow she got off the hook. Do you think she should have gotten jail time? Now 2 years later she ran off and got married, again without telling anyone. In my opinion, that situation apparently had no effect on her. Not enough for her to change her ways. What do you think?  

Julie --- 17 years ago -

I know a girl that went through the same thing. She got pregnant, but she was already a big girl so her mother just thought she was putting on weight. She gave birth in the bathroom. Her mother walked in on it. The baby lived. I think they put her in therapy. She was in denial her whole pregnancy. People can go out of their minds when they try to deny it. I don't know if that was the case with your friend. But I don't know that jail time would be something she would need. Therapy yes. (sorry for sp y'all) 

cayetx --- 17 years ago -

Well, did she even get checkups for the baby? If not, then she already knew she was putting the baby in danger and didn't care. I guess we'd have to know more...before I would be 100% for it...but I think she should've gotten something. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

...Well, was she physically able to call 911? You'd have to prove that first. Well she was able to walk to the bathroom so i would assume so..?? its not like it happened instantly. But i think she should have gotten jail time because she knew for several months that she was responsible for another persons life and she just didnt care and as a result the baby died. If she didnt want it she should have at least gotten help, had the baby at a hospital, and gave it up for adoption. Thats just my opinion though. 

Sara --- 17 years ago -

I was gonna say the same thing cayetx. Did she have any prenatal care? Was their an autopsy on the infant? I'm not sticking up for her, cause it's an awful thing, but there are babies that are stillborn, and I'm wondering if this could have been a cause. You can do everything right, and still have the misfortune of having something wrong with your baby. I think that she honestly needs help, even today, especially now that she's run away again. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

but there are babies that are stillborn, I guess i left that part out... The baby died because he got wrapped in the umbilical cord on the way out of her... If she would have gotten proper care he would still be alive. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

No. It doesn't seem intentional. Just a sad scared young girl. I blame shit like this on the "fathers". If guys would man up and not leave girls scared and alone I bet these incidents would be less. 

Troublemaker --- 17 years ago -

I don't mean this case in particular I kind of went off topic. But I think a lot of the problems come from guys running away. For a crime to take place there has to be intent and I don't see her intent here. She has to live with this for the rest of her life and I think will probaly have flashbacks and nightmares forever. None of us were there so who can say for sure. Now if it's proven she did this on pupose than the bi^&h can rot in jail forever as far as I'm concerned. But that's why we have the police and hopefully they find out the truth. 

SemperFiChic --- 17 years ago -

No, she shouldn't get jail time, she should be shot and save the taxpayers money. She's beyond a detriment to society and therefore shouldn't be allowed to be a part of it. This is the perfect answer...I couldn't agree more! 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't seem intentional. Just a sad scared young girl Wether it was her intent for him to die or not she could have gotten help. There are alot of women out there who cant have babies and this one could have been in a happy home where someone would love him and take care of him. The regret of putting him in a happy home would be far less painful than the regret of letting him die. And if she wasnt able to handle the consequences she shouldnt have had sex to begin with. And i agree with you about the father part in her situation... her father was never around. She may have been young, but she was old enough to know to get help if you ask me. 

*shenanigans* --- 17 years ago -

Wether it was her intent for him to die or not she could have gotten help. There are alot of women out there who cant have babies and this one could have been in a happy home where someone would love him and take care of him. The regret of putting him in a happy home would be far less painful than the regret of letting him die. And if she wasnt able to handle the consequences she shouldnt have had sex to begin with. And i agree with you about the father part in her situation... her father was never around. She may have been young, but she was old enough to know to get help if you ask me. I ABSOLUTLY 150% AGREE WITH YOU ON THIS! The CAPS is because I am serious!! 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

Society says no more spanking kids as toddlers and this sort of thing happens later in life. A little discipline in her life probably would have fixed the whole thing. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I also think any woman that get pregnant under the age of 18 should be jailed for having sex to young and the kid put up for adoption, no choice for her at all. If you are not 18 you have no rights. 

*shenanigans* --- 17 years ago -

Society says no more spanking kids as toddlers and this sort of thing happens later in life. A little discipline in her life probably would have fixed the whole thing. I agree, a little spank or two when she was younger may have given her some life lessons.. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

I also think any woman that get pregnant under the age of 18 should be jailed for having sex to young and the kid put up for adoption, no choice for her at all. If you are not 18 you have no rights. I dont agree with that. I got pregnant at 17. But i was also married. But in colorado when an underage girl gets pregnant, her parents have legal rights to the baby until she is 18 is what i heard. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I dont agree with that. I got pregnant at 17. But i was also married. But in colorado when an underage girl gets pregnant, her parents have legal rights to the baby until she is 18 is what i heard. Getting pregnant at 16 is vaginal irresponsibility and should be punishable. If you were married that is between you and your husband. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

I agree, a little spank or two when she was younger may have given her some life lessons.. Your probably right. And the fact that her mother was very strict was helpful either but its still no excuse for what she did. Thats why i am not going to sit up my childs a$$ and i will guide him, but i will ultimately let him find out for himself because if i do sit up his butt about what not to do.... he will do it just because i said not to, and he wont tell me. Thats how i feel now, but i guess we will see if i stick to that when hes older lol 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I was terrified of making my dad mad. That is the way it should be. 

cayetx --- 17 years ago -

Well...we don't know whether or not the guy knew. If she was too scared to tell her mom she was pregnant, she prob didnt want to tell the father either. A wrapped umbilical cord could have been easily saved if she was getting prenatal care or even just showed up at the hospital for labor. I guess the mother and daughter weren't that close for her to confide in her. I agree with Mr. God...we pay enough so prisoners get better health care than most of America, even a roof over their heads. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

wrapped umbilical cord could have been easily saved if she was getting prenatal care or even just showed up at the hospital for labor I totally agree with you. She didnt even have to tell her mom if she was that scared... where we grew up there were 2 free clinics that offered help and were confidential. They even had a free class an hour a week (if you were pregnant) and all you had to do was sit there and watch a video. They would give you "baby bucks" and and when you earned enough you could get anything you want for your baby wether it be clothes, carseat, crib.... anything!!! I think everywhere should have some kind of program like that. (sorry kinda off topic) 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I totally agree with you. She didnt even have to tell her mom if she was that scared... where we grew up there were 2 free clinics that offered help and were confidential. They even had a free class an hour a week (if you were pregnant) and all you had to do was sit there and watch a video. They would give you "baby bucks" and and when you earned enough you could get anything you want for your baby wether it be clothes, carseat, crib.... anything!!! I think everywhere should have some kind of program like that. (sorry kinda off topic) I gotta disagree. Underage pregnant girls should be ostracized and shamed along with he guy that knocked them up. Not offered handouts and games. Maybe if it were not for programs like that and that stupid TV show on MTV in addition to a little more parenting, this wouldn't be as big of a problem. 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

Maybe your right, but its not like it will stop teens from getting pregnant so they still need things to offer help IMO. Maybe if there were more classed like that there would be less abortions and people who dont tell anyone. 

cayetx --- 17 years ago -

It's just the world today. Shows wouldn't be on TV unless they knew there was going to be a good sized audience. I read a story about a bunch of teenage girls (15,16 yrs) that made a pact to get pregnant the same time so they could raise their children together and thought it was cool. There are just people who shouldn't procreate, imo. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe your right, but its not like it will stop teens from getting pregnant so they still need things to offer help IMO. Maybe if there were more classed like that there would be less abortions and people who dont tell anyone. It may not stop them, but I think it would help. You are correct about classes too. Civil disagreements! I love it! 

AJ :) --- 17 years ago -

Civil disagreements! I love it! Me too!!! :) lol (15,16 yrs) that made a pact to get pregnant the same time so they could raise their children together and thought it was cool. That is soooo dumb!!! Your right, they shouldnt. 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

I think her mom should have got jail time for not seeing that her child was pregnant. Im sure if my daughter was pregnant I would notice something. 

cayetx --- 17 years ago -

Some people can hide it well. In high school, a girl was pregnant and no one knew until she was in the hospital giving birth. She was a little overweight but appeared to not have gained/showed during pregnancy. She was on the high school dance too and remained active. 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

Some people can hide it well. In high school, a girl was pregnant and no one knew until she was in the hospital giving birth. She was a little overweight but appeared to not have gained/showed during pregnancy. She was on the high school dance too and remained active. Thre is more than just showing. There are all kinds of signs that as a mother how can you miss if you are close to your child ya know 

InYoFace --- 17 years ago -

She's totally wrong and should suffer something, but I don't think it should be jail. There are much worse crimes, and this situation has so many variables its ridiculous. 

cayetx --- 17 years ago -

Thre is more than just showing. There are all kinds of signs that as a mother how can you miss if you are close to your child ya know True...i think she acutally didn't live with her mother though...she had a crazy fam. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground