I need some opinions on spanking. I have a 4 year old boy who does not listen to anything I say. I do time outs awaywell as taking stuff away (movies,toys, etc...)and they do not work. I do not spank him as I was raised not being spanked. On the other hand my husband was raised being spanked. I kinda don't know which to do. Here's my reasoning...
Why should we spank our children? We are teaching them it is not ok to hit,then we go spank them. and "if you don't listen I will hurt you" is basically what it is. That doesn't seem right to me.
But...if you look at older generations that were spanked (I think there is a lot less spanking these days), and you look at how much more children respected their parents and other, they listened, and so on. There wasn't a big power struggle between children and parents because the children knew it would be their butt.
So...if anyone has any advice it would be greatly appreciated = )
I dont think there is anything wrong with a smack on the butt. I think its only effective if you explain to the child why he/she is getting the spanking. I cant stand people who just smack the crap out of their children, when I was in Hawaii I saw a woman pull down her childs pants and spank hiim in public, I thinnk that was UNCALLED for.
I don't spank my children. The time out method on the stairs works for us. You have to be consistent with the punishment and if they get up, you just put them right back.
I agree...It comes to the point where I now don't have to spank..I just say I will give you till three and then I will spank, and poof by 2 we are doing what I want.
I don't spank to hurt him but it really hurts his feelings more than anything!
I am personally all for spankings, I was spanked as a kid, and I knew right from wrong. I learned quick. I respected and still do respect my parents. I am all for corporal punishment! And I FULLY intend on enforcing the spanking rules in my house!
its not him hurting anyone or himself...its just...for example...
i told him not to play on the vacuum this evening and he got off i walked into the other room, came back, and he was on it again. stuff like that. and i take stuff away for quite away and if its late them i take it away till the morning.
Spanking isn't about hurting the child. It is a negative reinforcement, hopefully curbing the behavior you are trying to stop. My husband and I definitely believe in spankings. We also grew up getting spanked and turned out just fine.
i told him not to play on the vacuum this evening and he got off i walked into the other room, came back, and he was on it again. stuff like that.
Show him how to use it!
its not him hurting anyone or himself...its just...for example...
i told him not to play on the vacuum this evening and he got off i walked into the other room, came back, and he was on it again. stuff like that. and i take stuff away for quite away and if its late them i take it away till the morning.
Thats when you say...get off or I am going to swat your butt. If he doens't get off swat.
BEAT EM! LoL JKJK. My kids squat a minute for their age, and if they push the boundaries, they get a good whoopin, however old they are is how many whoopins they get.
Spanking isn't about hurting the child. It is a negative reinforcement, hopefully curbing the behavior you are trying to stop. My husband and I definitely believe in spankings. We also grew up getting spanked and turned out just fine.
I agree. I dont nor would I ever beat my child. However after a warning doesnt work I will pop them on the bottom and that does work. I have tried time outs as well and for mine it didnt work. Neither did taking things away.
Ive tried to spank him twice...
once i had to wrestle him down cuz he was going all over so i couldn't get him...
the other time it hurt my hand and he was still laughing lol
Ive tried to spank him twice...
once i had to wrestle him down cuz he was going all over so i couldn't get him...
the other time it hurt my hand and he was still laughing lol
WOW if a 4 yr old is laughing at you when you spank him then there is something wrong. Is he used to you not following through with discipline.
he does spank him sometimes. but what about when he is deployed or at work...he needs to know that mommy has just as much authority as daddy... or more = ) hehe
i guess ill just have to try it out and see if that's what will work
thanks for all the advice = )
Ive tried to spank him twice...
once i had to wrestle him down cuz he was going all over so i couldn't get him...
the other time it hurt my hand and he was still laughing lolĀ
Wow that sounds like a total lack of respect for you. You've got some other things to fix with him :(
i guess he is used to me not following through. in my mind i always make excuses like...maybe he didn't hear me or maybe he just needs some attention or something and i don't punish him or i wait until i tell him 5 times.