Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

cleaning bedroom

who's talking here?

Leaving Oki soon 1
Mrs. Taken 1
MOMZ 1
Mary 1
glitter mixed with rock & roll 1
Lizzie Borden 1
nikita08 1
Lovely 1
Soccer mom 2
Girlie Girl 2
Peone 1
Sam 1
OkiCrafter 1
lil bit 1
Nobia 1
LizzyB 2
Semper Fi 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Semper Fi --- 17 years ago -

Ok ladies....I need some help. I have a daughter that is almost 4. I struggle with her almost everyday to clean her room. I purchased totes to separate items (toys, animals, dolls) and a bookcase/nightstand for books and games. I have to constantly stay on her for 2 up to 10 hrs to get her to clean it up and nothing works. When I say nothing works I mean NOTHING. I have tried grounding, time out, corner, whippings, taking all toys away and putting them in storage. Ive tried bribing, paying, pleading, rewarding, and anything else you could think of. She is so stubborn. I just don't know what to do anymore. My husband and I feel like we have tried everything and are just so frustrated. Does anyone have ANY suggestions as to how I can get her to just clean her room. 

OkiCrafter --- 17 years ago -

I have tried grounding, time out, corner, whippings, taking all toys away and putting them in storage. Have you tried helping her and making it fun? Sing songs (clean up, clean up. Whistle while we work, etc) 

glitter mixed with rock & roll --- 17 years ago -

My daughter is just over one and a half and we are working on picking things up. If she sees me doing it and pretending t have fun while singing or whatever, then she joins in and we actually have fun! 

lil bit --- 17 years ago -

2 up to 10 hrs .... sounds like she is in "control" of the house. (please don't be offended)..but if neither you or dad can get results..then that is why I said this. Put away a bulk of her toys. Maybe she has too many and needs to be limited to just one-two toys or items at a time. When she is done playing with them, go into your storage of her toys and take more out as she learns to take care of just a limited amount. She maybe has been used to having what she wants, when she wants. I know you mentioned that storage didn't work..how long were they kept away. Were they given back to her after she was following clean-up rules? Is she an only child? Does she have any other children to follow or lead by example? Show her how you clean up in the house..and use it as examples with her own things. Continue with a reward type system or chart (with stickers) as you mentioned. Stay consistent. Maybe have specific play times (with her toys) during the day, along with outside play, etc..so she learns a "schedule" of things. For example once mommy is done letting you play, we clean up and then it is time for a snack..At this age they are very independent, strong willed and did I mention stubborn (as you know already)..but stay patient, calm, and try not to be frustrated. She will eventually learn as long as you don't give in :). If she is in another environment as well where she also learns this it is helpful too. (ie: preschool, daycare, playgroup). Hang in there! :) 

Mary --- 17 years ago -

I understand how you feel! If my son turns out to be anything like my husband where cleaning is concerned, I may as well quit the military in favour of becoming a maid! It is frustrating, and I don't even have a child for another month... :) 

Semper Fi --- 17 years ago -

well she is not in control of the house and I dont give in. When I say I want the room clean she doesnt leave the room until it is done, no exceptions. I started when she was about 2 helping her clean her room, showing her where everything goes and of course singing the clean up song. The deal is she MUST clean her room every night before bedtime. It is so weird, I take her to play morning and she cleans up just fine there. I am a stay at home mom and keep my children on a very good schedule. We are not indulgent(spelling) parents. We believe that you earn what you receive, and gifts and toys are not given willy nilly. She is just really digging her heels in over this. I have been trying for 2 years to teach her to have pride in her personal space. Some of my other friends have children of the same age and they dont seem to be having this problem. I really am about two seconds away from throwing away everything in her room except her bed. 

Girlie Girl --- 17 years ago -

Unfortunately it just sounds like a "battle of will" those toddlers can be pretty stubborn as you well know. Our 4 year old son rocks at cleaning up (even better than my 10 year old)...BUT we went though the same thing. Finally what worked for him was just making it a big deal one day a week (Sunday). And now we're doing every other day and that works great for him. Be patient she'll get it :) 

Peone --- 17 years ago -

I remember as a kid I wanted to help my mother do everything then I learned and it became my chore. So for my son I ask him if he wants to help me and normaly wants to do what ever I am doing. Maybe if you try to set a time everyday that the two of you clean up her room together it might work. if she is doing it on her own it might seem to much at one time or she starts to play instead. Make it a mommy and daughter time. 

Sam --- 17 years ago -

I may be wrong, but I think every child needs consistency. Maybe trying everything is what the problem is. If I were you, based on what you wrote, I would stick with one thing and follow through with it 100 percent of the time. You could start by removing any toys she doesn't play with from the room, and either getting rid of them or rotating them and keeping the unused ones somewhere to switch with the used ones later on...that way, she won't have so much to make a mess out of. Maybe part of the problem is having too much stuff. If your trying to make it her responsibility to keep her room clean, it makes sense to give her something she can handle at 4, no? Then, pick a routine and stick with it. Say, shes only allowed to have one or two toys out at a time. Correct her if she doesn't pick it up. If she argues or gets another toy without cleaning it up, take it away and put it somewhere she can see it, then ignore how she reacts to it until she reacts the way you are requesting. Good luck, anyways! 

Soccer mom --- 17 years ago -

Unfortunately it just sounds like a "battle of will" those toddlers can be pretty stubborn as you well know I agree. Sounds like she knows that is what gets mom's attention. Children will take the attention anyway they can get it. Even when it is negative. She is old enough know that she knows this is something that she will have your attention for 2 to 10 hours. 

MOMZ --- 17 years ago -

I like the idea of assisting them with the cleaning. Especially at that age. I think I need to use that with my 7 year old. LOL. She is horrible. HORRIBLE! I suppose when we scream and all that jazz it just gets discouraging. Time to pep up the game of cleaning room with whistleing and cheering. :)))) 

Semper Fi --- 17 years ago -

I guess I just didnt think it would be like this. I have had chore as long as I can remember. I keep a very clean house and my daughter loves to help clean up. She always wants to help dust, windex, vaccum, and I let her. I just cant help but wonder where I went wrong. I guess every child is different, and she just needs a little more coaxing than other children. Im sure everyone is right. Ill just have to continue to work with her and hopefully she will grow into a more tidy child...eventually:) 

Soccer mom --- 17 years ago -

Don't be so hard on yourself. You did not go wrong anywhere. Parenting is trial and error. Something might work one day and not the next. That is why our wonderful little kiddos don't come with an owner's manual. LOL! 

Girlie Girl --- 17 years ago -

Keep your chin up :) 

LizzyB --- 17 years ago -

I take all my kids toys away! ALL of them! They don't want to take care of them, they don't deserve them. Sometimes we just downsize if the rooms are becoming to cluttered. If they want them back, they have to earn them back.. My kids are 4, 3 and almost 2. I played that 2-10hrs game. taking TV away, grounding etc. Only thing that works is to let your kids think you are a little bit crazy. Take the toys. Obviously they don't care about them that much. I've also taken the toys they "don't want" and they've donated them to the Children's orphanage. Now they realize if they don't want a toy enough to keep up with it, they know what I will do so when I say clean up, they do. On a rare occasion they ask me if they can sell/donate their toys they no longer play with. No, I don't help my kids pick up their messes either. They made the mess. I expect them to clean up their mess. I make a mess I clean it up. I ask them to "When Mommy makes a mess do you clean it up?" "No." So if you make a mess should Mommy clean it up?" "No" Smart kid. LoL. No, and life doesn't work like that either. Other people are not going to clean up your messes and for those who think others should/will... hmmm. They help me clean up the house, like the bathroom, laundry, dishes because we all make that mess together. We even have two vacuums. They vacuum their own rooms and help me vacuum the rest of the house as well. It's cute seeing my 2yr old vacuum :). He LOVES it to. For now. 

Nobia --- 17 years ago -

When my son couldn't pick up after himself, I decided he had too many toys. We cut the amount of toys in half. He was heartbroken. But getting him to be responsible about picking up has been a breeze since. He knows I'm serious. I would never be able to argue 10 hours about cleaning a room, I'd have thrown the stuff out the window long before lol. 

LizzyB --- 17 years ago -

 

Lovely --- 17 years ago -

Semper fi you sound like me with my 3 year old daughter. I raised a 18 year son and a 17 year old daughter and they were never like how she is. Every child is different, some you just take more time with things then others. 

Semper Fi --- 17 years ago -

No, I don't help my kids pick up their messes either. They made the mess. I expect them to clean up their mess. I make a mess I clean it up. Im glad someone else feels the same way. Im responsible for the rest of the house so I feel like she should be responsible for her own space. I am very consistent. I dont think her room has to be perfect, but i want it picked up EVERY night before bed and I dont give in. I have even thrown her toys away. One day she had a mess of toys in the living room and I told her to pick the up an take them to her room. She refused and I told her If I had to pick them up they were going straight in the trash. She still refused so I threw every one of them away. She for real looked at me and said "I dont care". I have already gone through most of her toys and "cleaned house" because we have a baby that when is sleeping through the night will move in to my daughters room. I know what I have to do, it is just a shame it has to be that way. I hate it that our days are spent fighting over this instead of outside playing or doing fun things. Most of the time it would only take her about 10 min to pick up, but she just has to be stubborn and make an all day affair out of it. 

Semper Fi --- 17 years ago -

My mom says this is my payback :) 

Leaving Oki soon --- 17 years ago -

I take all my kids toys away! ALL of them! They don't want to take care of them, they don't deserve them. I've been doing that with my daughter toys too. I tell her if I see one toy out of her room or on the floor I'll trow it away and it works...but she still won't clean up her room. She made up a song the other day about how much she hates cleaning up her room. She told me that she would clean the whole house for me if I do her room so that's what we are doing now and she's 7. 

Lizzie Borden --- 17 years ago -

I purchased totes to separate items (toys, animals, dolls) and a bookcase/nightstand for books and games. I have to constantly stay on her for 2 up to 10 hrs to get her to clean it up and nothing works. When I say nothing works I mean NOTHING. I have tried grounding, time out, corner, whippings, taking all toys away and putting them in storage. Ive tried bribing, paying, pleading, rewarding, and anything else you could think of. How about PRAISING for what lil bit she may do and it may develope into more production from her. I almost thought I was reading my own life. I was going through the very same issue proably as you were posting. My daughter is 5 and I made totes for Dress up, baby accessories, barbie lil pet shop ect.. Last night I notice that she just put the things back in her closet where ever. She was proud that the floor was clean. I praised her for cleaning the floor but explained that mommy had different totes for different toys. I wanted to experiment and see if this is too much for her age. I mean she has the idea that her room was clean, she worked hard. and notthing was on the floor. So I had her pull the totes out and take the lids off. Had her tell me what each tote was for. I sat on the floor and asked her to get one thing at a time out of the closet and tell me what tote it went in. It kind of became a game to her. My husband came in the middle and got in the way trying to help her. Not knowing what I was doing. Thats another topic. He assumed I was sitting on my arse being a mean mom. But thats something else. Anyway I told her that when her friends come over that before they leave or whenever its time for her to clean up that she should pull all the totes out and take the lids off and put away one item at a time. I also made sure she could put the lids back on and put them away. So today is a new day. and we will see how it goes. Just be patient and remeber she is 4 not 14. The world is so big to her and deep down she wants to please you and be acknowledged for it. Trial and error.. for the both of you... 

Mrs. Taken --- 17 years ago -

Maybe when it comes time to pick up her room she is tired and we all know a tired toddler the evening is going accomplish nothing.My kids have what we call "fussy hr" after 5 until bed time. Try having her room done by 5 and then she is only aloud 1 toy or item out at a time after that. Just a thought :) 

nikita08 --- 17 years ago -

I don't know if someone suggested this yet or not...but this is what I did when I helped raise my god daughter... We got to the point where I was actually setting the limit on toys, like if she took a couple puzzles out and got bored with them she would wanna go get something else out.. NOPE. I would flat out tell her either you pick up the puzzles and put them away first, or no more toys. We battled for awhile, but when she threw her fit I completely ignored it, she would try to go get toys, I simply would either go get her put her back in the other room, close the door to they toys or put them up higher ect. Eventually she got the idea that hey I want to play with other things but if I don't pick it up I don't get anything else. Also when we were picking toys up, I would make it a game. I would tell it was a race to see who could pick up the most toys the quickest and would get down there with her, and she had a blast!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground