Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: do you think women should be allowed to be part of grunt units?

who's talking here?

Just another girl 3
Wish you were me 1
Kitty 1
Mrs. Taken 1
peachyme 1
boone 1
Ennui 5
YakkoZakko 1
Amanda 2
MRSBUHBUHBANKS 1
Paul 1
Jennifer 3
lil bit 1
Krystle 5
Ali 1
MaryVon 5
Caitlin 1
Bryn 1
mwr885 1
Blue Falcon 3
*AlLiSoN* 1
dannielle 1
Wombat Jewce 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: do you think women should be allowed to be part of grunt units?

as a former active duty female marine do you think women should be allowed to serve with grunt units?

yes Vote
 
 34.2% (13)
no Vote
 
 52.6% (20)
who cares Vote
 
 13.2% (5)
Just another girl --- 17 years ago -

as a former active duty female marine do you think women should be allowed to serve with grunt units? 

MRSBUHBUHBANKS --- 17 years ago -

Motherly instinct. Its just not a good fit. 

Mrs. Taken --- 17 years ago -

Motherly instinct. Its just not a good fit. I say no as I wife Instinct :) Not that I don't trust my hubby, I just feel better knowing he is working around men in certain situations :) 

*AlLiSoN* --- 17 years ago -

i am a female in the air force as a cop. I see nothing wrong with it. 

Just another girl --- 17 years ago -

i dont see anything wrong with it either. the whole motherly instinct thing shouldnt even be brought up. they joined the service to do a job and thats to defend their country. they are trained in bootcamp just like males, they go through combat training so why not let them. in my last unit right before my eas they were finally allowing females to deploy with grunt units. 

lil bit --- 17 years ago -

As a former soldier in a Forward Support Battalion we were very vital in our role in supporting the grunts. It even helped push some of the male soldiers to work harder just as it did the females when it came to Physical Fitness, road marches, Airborne/Air Assault etc.. It's a different military now though, as my hubby reminds me; America is still at War, so alot of things have changed because missions are different. As long as the female is physically staying in shape, performing/doing their job they've been trained to do and helping to accomplish the mission then why not? Jobs have broadened for females as a whole because they are proving that they are able to perform in those job categories. I believe alot of old school military prefer it as it was old school. But just as things are~there is always change. When they see it doesn't work any longer..then again..change. The beautiful thing is that females and males alike are doing one thing together and that is serving their country. Something not everyone can commit to doing! 

peachyme --- 17 years ago -

what is a grunt unit? 

YakkoZakko --- 17 years ago -

here is my theory on why females can't do infantry you have to be not noticeable to the enemy and us females have a monthly friend that gives out a certain smell and the enemy can train dogs to hunt out that smell 

Amanda --- 17 years ago -

what is a grunt unit? my hubbys airforce and he says hes never heard of it, so what is it?? 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

what is a grunt unit? Grunt unit for what I know are the Marines that are on the front line while in wars or expeditions . A friend of ours is Grunt...And thats what he does. 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

what is a grunt unit? grunts are the marines that fight in the frontline 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

here is my theory on why females can't do infantry you have to be not noticeable to the enemy and us females have a monthly friend that gives out a certain smell and the enemy can train dogs to hunt out that smell Contrary to that, having dogs with them might give away their own location. 

Wish you were me --- 17 years ago -

Equal opportunity where did that go ...... so i say definitely yes if they want to 

Amanda --- 17 years ago -

i say yes they should be allowd if they want to 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

If a woman fits the criteria and does the job as required then I don't think that they should be denied. If anyone man or woman can't do the job they shouldn't be able to be in that unit, battalion or whatever it is called (sorry I don't know). Man or woman IMHO it's about getting the job done and that is to say the men working with those women should be professional enough to treat them as one of the group. If they can't work in a group regardless sex, race religion or otherwise they are not a team player and being a team player is part of the job description is it not? 

Blue Falcon --- 17 years ago -

Blue Falcon here to answer away and save the day.......Females are not allowed on the front lines with GRUNTs for the following reason. 1. Emotional persuasion (ex. when captured males will succumb to torture when issued on a female as a point of emotional weakness where as with another male they would expect them to be better conditioned to with stand the onslaught) 2. Fraternaly unity (ex. when male units are trained together even when all do not see eye to eye training is completed and emotion is set aside for the purpose of the mission. When females have been introduced, to previously mentioned units the following occurs in similar instances. Emotional attachment or separation due to disagreement and or manipulative persuation (whether intentional or not) will cause decision to be made that will effect the out come a mission adversly.) 3. Final note Sexual tension (ex. while deployed away from loved ones or significant others if you like, sexual tension becomes more noticable and reactions to otherwise unnoticed advances are acted on.) In short, men act more normal around other men and think more logically. Men around women think with the small brain and make less than logical choices. All those that would disagree, look at the young male Marine in two environments and try to disprove me. One environment when in the presence of all males (see them fit and still be friends even if alcohol is involved), now same even with female in imediate area (fitting becomes serious and friendships are ended especially when alcohol is involved.) 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

ex. while deployed away from loved ones or significant others if you like, sexual tension becomes more noticable and reactions to otherwise unnoticed advances are acted on.) Yeah, i could see that happening..Men dont think like us. 

boone --- 17 years ago -

I've touched on this topic before (in a different thread months ago) and everyone came at me! My answer was NO, and it will always be no. 

mwr885 --- 17 years ago -

I actually got asked this on an awards board once a long time ago. My answer was "Are you confident that your 120lb frame can pick up my 240lbs and run with it out of harms way should I get hurt?" Needless to say I did not win Sailor of the quarter and that particular PS1 never did like me anymore. But the question still stands... 

dannielle --- 17 years ago -

what is a grunt unit? grunts are the marines that fight in the frontline grunts are infantry.they know there weapon like the back of their hand as well as more different weapons and more hand to hand combat than us marines sitting behind desks.... my brother was a grunt and he knew how to make weapons out of everything..... even an mre bomb 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

In short, it isn't about the lack of ability on a female's part but how their male counterparts handle having a member of the opposite sex amongst them. :> That tells us PLENTY! 

Blue Falcon --- 17 years ago -

Thank you all for your understanding, As for as MRE Bombs..........every Marine knows that trick. I have worked with plenty of Grunts and they are exceptional with weaponry, but the MRE bomb should not be added into that classification. BLUE FALCON AAAAAWWWWWWWAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY 

Wombat Jewce --- 17 years ago -

personal opinion-> they don't belong in the MC >:O 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

personal opinion-> they don't belong in the MC >:O As a personal opinion too, now that just was mean. 

Jennifer --- 17 years ago -

Okay, I don't think so really.... but here is my reason. Someone I saw had mentioned the monthly gift. Yeah, maybe they won't send dogs out to search but, aren't the men on the front lines also the ones who basically have to sleep in holes? wherever they basically can? Where are you going to be able to change that crap out? Also, when men need to take a pee, they can just whip it out. Women have to take all the time just to be able to get through all the gear to pull their pants down. What are they going to do, put a catheter in them before they head out?! I don't think it would be a bad thing for women to be able to do it, but it's the everyday things that would make it very complicated. I could be wrong though. 

Jennifer --- 17 years ago -

personal opinion-> they don't belong in the MC >:O As a personal opinion too, now that just was mean. you said it nicer than I was going to MaryVon.... lmao.... 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

you said it nicer than I was going to MaryVon.... lmao.... Ah trust me, I tried to be as much civil as possible. 

Jennifer --- 17 years ago -

Ah trust me, I tried to be as much civil as possible. yeah, I had actually typed in something else, but at the last moment I realized it would be better to just agree with you ;) 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

..... even an mre bomb ha ha I can make an MRE bomb... can I be a grunt? 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

ha ha I can make an MRE bomb... can I be a grunt? No Gurl!!..you cant pfftt...But if you give me 100 bucks I can give you a paper that says so:) 100% legitim!! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground