Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Suicide?

who's talking here?

Kitty 3
Mrs. Taken 1
Jamie (Sake's momma) 5
boone 1
Ennui 1
Lizzie Borden 1
Kathryn 2
banana4 1
Paul 2
Krystle 3
PoonStang 1
MaryVon 3
SouthernSweetheart 1
*Shelbysmomma* 2
lilloudymouth 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Suicide?

If suicide is the ultimate sin- (that would send you to hell)-- if the cancer kid refused chemo and died- would that be considered suicide?- would he go to hell for that?? I am not religious- and I was just thinking about this... Just curious is all.

Suicide? yes- hell? no Vote
 
 5.0% (1)
Suicide? yes- hell? yes Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Suicide? no Vote
 
 80.0% (16)
Other- please explain. Vote
 
 15.0% (3)
Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

If suicide is the ultimate sin- (that would send you to hell)-- if the cancer kid refused chemo and died- would that be considered suicide?- would he go to hell for that?? I am not religious- and I was just thinking about this... Just curious is all. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Anyone else?? 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

This is a very complicated topic. 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

I believe suicide to be a sin only when you pull the plug yourself. You want to die. Fast death. Fast solution. Who really wants to die slowly? Though the boy with cancer may be letting himself die when he refused chemo, he doesn't want to die. WANT is the key word. 

Lizzie Borden --- 17 years ago -

I am thru with the religion comments for tonight.. I am going to bed and say my hail mary's Night... This is too much... 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

There is no hell so who f'n cares how you die? Are you sure? 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

I don't mean to offend or start a heated post.. I will lock it if it gets out of line. I am just curious since I am not religious.. my views are if you are a bad person and bad things your after life won't be white clouds and good times.. 

MaryVon --- 17 years ago -

Only time will tell but I'm willing to bet my life on it. Yup,cant agree more, this is why I can have an idea, but I dont bet on it because I don't know. 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

If you aren't religious, why are you concerned about an afterlife? You don't have to be religious to wonder, it's called "Philosophy' 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

I say that dying of cancer is a natural thing, even before chemo treatments were available people still died of cancer. Unnatural ways that you plan yourself would be different in my eyes. I'm not religious as well. 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

??? You mean mythology? Nah, I know what I said. :) 

Kathryn --- 17 years ago -

phi⋅los⋅o⋅phy –noun, plural -phies. 1. the rational investigation of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, or conduct. my⋅thol⋅o⋅gy –noun, plural -gies. 1. a body of myths, as that of a particular people or that relating to a particular person: Greek mythology. 

Krystle --- 17 years ago -

??? You mean mythology? Ahh i see, in your case yes. ;) 

lilloudymouth --- 17 years ago -

No, he isnt taking his own life. The cancer is killing him. Its completely different IMO 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

Jamie, are you ok? Is there a reason you started a post about suicide? 

SouthernSweetheart --- 17 years ago -

i think considering he cant help the state he is in, it has nothing to do with suicide. but thats just me.. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Oh.. I was just thinking about it- I didn't want to ask the religious chick at work- cause she already thinks I am satan since I don't really believe in "her" God.. She says you cannot be kind-of Christian- you either are or you're not... I am not full blown Christian by any means- but you don't have to be full blown to believe bits and pieces- here and there. lol But thanks for asking, I am fine :) 

Paul --- 17 years ago -

There is no hell so who f'n cares how you die? Ever been to Kansas???? 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

To answer your question IMO: There is a difference between taking your life when you are perfectly healthy and capable of continuing life on your own and causes out of your control causing your death. I do not believe that refusing care would be considered "suicide" anymore then say, dying when attempting something dangerous. Dying of things other then "old age" or literally "natural causes" happens all of the time but I truly feel that unless you are intentionally doing something without any home of surviving that is another story. Let's not forget too, there are very religious people out there that believe that "God" will cure them without the help of modern medicine. Whether you believe it or not they are out there. *shrug* 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

If you aren't religious, why are you concerned about an afterlife?  just because you are not religious does not mean that you do not believe in an afterlife or something that happens to you after you pass away from the living. 

*Shelbysmomma* --- 17 years ago -

wow what an in depth poll. i think things like this all the time. 

*Shelbysmomma* --- 17 years ago -

my mom has cancer and has taken 3 round of chemo and 3 rounds of radiation but now choses to stop with the treatment. just bc she chose to stop treatment doesnt mean shes going to hell. i think some people just chose to live their last few months or years being happy not in pain. 

Kitty --- 17 years ago -

I also think it's how seriously you take your religious beliefs too. The definition of suicide is one thing but hell is another. If you are catholic for example there are a LOT of things that would "damn you to hell" that many people make part of their everyday life some without even thinking that it is problematic. (rhetorical) So how strictly do you follow your own religion? you know. . . 

Mrs. Taken --- 17 years ago -

My Grandfather was dying of lung cancer, he culd not even get up to go to the bathroom without having a breathing treatment, he shot and killed himself in his backyard. He was on Hospice and had what they say was less then 3 weeks to live. But severe depression and pain can make one do crazy things. He was a very religious man, in his letter to my grandmother he said he shot himself in the stomach so he would have time to ask for forgivness. I dont think he went to Hell, I wish he had not done it in such a painful way but to him the obly way was so he would have time to ask god for forgivness 

banana4 --- 17 years ago -

I was seriously just thinking about this story yesterday, how weird is that? Anyway, I haven't read anything on it, just heard the quick sentence or two on AFN. One of my Gramps is Jehovah's Witness, I don't know anything about his religion, but I do know that if something were to happen to him, because of his religion he would refuse any blood transfusion. Kind of similar. 

boone --- 17 years ago -

The pastor at Koza this past weekend said that the only unforgivable sin is to not believe in God. 

Jamie (Sake's momma) --- 17 years ago -

Thanks for not turning this into a crazy thread ya'll :) 

PoonStang --- 17 years ago -

There is no hell so who f'n cares how you die? if Mr. God says there is no hell... there is no hell... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground