Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Spanking lowers IQ

who's talking here?

Kitten17 1
Ennui 3
Lizzie Borden 1
┌∩┐(◕_ 1
Loved living in Oki 1
Bryn 1
Nicole 5
Sara 1
Olivia 1
FGIALC 1
ChiTownGrl 1
Casey 2
4keeps 2
The Dramallama 2
❤☮& elbow grease 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bryn --- 17 years ago -

Click Me! Um okay. My IQ is 129, I was spanked often as a child. Am I dumb? No. Did I learn my lesson? Yes. Children are too fvcking pampered now-a-days and that's why there are so many disrespectful little brats. 

┌∩┐(◕_ --- 17 years ago -

I was spanked plenty. I am just fine today. A hard head makes a soft a$$. Spare the rod, (and you) spoil the child. 

FGIALC --- 17 years ago -

Does it lower my IQ if I'm the one that likes to give the spankings? 

Kitten17 --- 17 years ago -

Does it lower my IQ if I'm the one that likes to give the spankings? maybe is does the opposite and raises it 

The Dramallama --- 17 years ago -

From the article "if you're just spanking, you haven't taught your child anything." I sure has hell learned when my Dad spanked. Maybe the test subject were just morons to begin with. 

❤☮& elbow grease --- 17 years ago -

if you're just spanking, you haven't taught your child anything ha...That's so wrong...If you are spanking or giving any concequences you are teaching a cause and effect relationship to your kids... Do A after you've been warned get your butt spanked.. Do B get praise. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

I have to be the naysayer here. We've taken a completely different approach to discipline lately. We only spank if the situation truly warrants it-like when my son was messing with some stuff that was plugged in. We've seen a HUGE difference in behavior. Huge. He is much better at listening to us and doing what we ask. We've just gotten very serious about time out and natural/logical consequences. I have definitely decided our household is more pleasant and we get better behavior when we're not yelling or spanking. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

Oh and I agree with the statement that if "you're just spanking, you haven't taught your child anything." 

The Dramallama --- 17 years ago -

I have to be the naysayer here. We've taken a completely different approach to discipline lately. We only spank if the situation truly warrants it-like when my son was messing with some stuff that was plugged in. We've seen a HUGE difference in behavior. Huge. He is much better at listening to us and doing what we ask. We've just gotten very serious about time out and natural/logical consequences. I have definitely decided our household is more pleasant and we get better behavior when we're not yelling or spanking. We do the same thing, we have spankable and non-spankable offenses depending on the severity of the infraction. Oh and I agree with the statement that if "you're just spanking, you haven't taught your child anything." I guess it depends on the context of the quote. It seemed to me to be general statement about spanking. But if they are implying that the only thing being done is spanking I guess that makes a little sense. 

❤☮& elbow grease --- 17 years ago -

We have the same rules in my house, every offense does not warrant spanking.. We usually only spank when our children's actions could cause harm to someone, for example throwing toys or jumping off furniture repeatedly.. I still feel that any punishment shows your kids that actions have consequences, and the severity of the actions increases the type of punishment.. The worst or more severe being spanking. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

I guess it depends on the context of the quote. It seemed to me to be general statement about spanking. But if they are implying that the only thing being done is spanking I guess that makes a little sense. I think they mean that if your child misbehaves and you simply spank, you aren't doing anything other than physically punishing them. You aren't telling them specifically what they did wrong (which is important with a young child), you aren't telling them what they can do correctly, etc. You aren't "teaching" anything-except that if you deem them "bad" you'll hurt them. 

❤☮& elbow grease --- 17 years ago -

I agree with that... If spanking is the only form of punishment you use, and there is no communication with it.. I guess you probably aren't teaching your child much.. 

❤☮& elbow grease --- 17 years ago -

Doughnuts for breakfast probably lower your kids IQ as well... But I am thinking this might be a doughnut morning..LOL.. Maybe I'll make sure I don't spank today..lol 

Casey --- 17 years ago -

I just want to point out that a lot of times when they do these studies on spankings, that they generally study people who are on the low end of the income spectrum and often have single parents and other at risk factors as well. This article doesn't say anything about the children they tested, but it does say that they did not factor in any of these things. So basically, the study is not as conclusive as they want people to think it is. exactly. 

Loved living in Oki --- 17 years ago -

I was never spanked as a kid (I was an ANGEL)and I'm the smartest person I know. Although that could just say something about the people I hang out with. Eh. 

Casey --- 17 years ago -

I'm the smartest person I know. that's just because you don't know me. ;) 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

I was spanked too. Gee, spanked is actually a mild word for it. My mom really could hit up a storm. Do I feel dumb? No. I don't believe in spanking a child while you are angry. If you want to smack your child, do so by calling attention to what they have done wrong & make sure they can see your hand coming down. 

ChiTownGrl --- 17 years ago -

I think every kid is different. Some respond to spanking and others don't and parents need to adjust their methods to what works. It's pointless to spank if it doesn't do anything for the kid, just as timeouts are pointless for other kids. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

I think every kid is different. Some respond to spanking and others don't and parents need to adjust their methods to what works. It's pointless to spank if it doesn't do anything for the kid, just as timeouts are pointless for other kids. I 100% agree. I get awfully tired of everyone saying that kids just need to be spanked-and that parents are spoiling kids by not spanking them. We really have found that in our house, spanking doesn't work-especially if we are spanking for everything. And if we save the spanking for really, really bad things-wow, does it have an shocking effect. I get really sad when I see people spanking their babies (under 18 months or so). I get really, really sad when I see people spank (or slap hands, etc) of babies under 1. They are just too little and don't understand why they are being hurt. :( 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

I get really, really sad when I see people spank (or slap hands, etc) of babies under 1. I started slapping my tot's hands after he was 20 months. There comes a time when they need to know the meaning of NO & that going against NO means some pain. I've not gone further than slapping my kids' hand though. Don't believe it helps. 

Nicole --- 17 years ago -

There is a big difference in 8-9 months and 20 months. I've seen it done to an 8-9 month old. And spanked on the butt too. :( 

Ennui --- 17 years ago -

I've seen it done to an 8-9 month old. And spanked on the butt too. :( Yup, I know what you mean. Quite pointless to do that. The poor baby doesn't know what's happening! 

4keeps --- 17 years ago -

I tell my child before they get it and sometimes during! I do however have a problem with my temper and yell alot. I'm working on that though:) I don't have "guide line" as far as spanking goes, if i feel that they need it, then they get it. My children get off light compared to the beatings I got growing up. My mom found out that I along with the neighborhood kids were doing something bad (jumping out of bushes at cars)anyways i was 5 and didn't really understand that it was so bad. Well, she made me take a bath and she told me when i was done to get out and go to my room w/out drying off. Yeah, she came in there and spanked with a leather belt, mind you i had wet skin! 

4keeps --- 17 years ago -

That sounds like some kind of weird fetish your mom had. I mean that seriously. That's.. that has me feeling like washing with some steel wool. No, she was just MEAN!!! Thank God I didn't have to do that! 

Lizzie Borden --- 17 years ago -

No, she was just MEAN!!! Thank God I didn't have to do that! That is not mean.. its beyond mean.. it's cruel, I am sorry you had to live like that. That sounds like some kind of weird fetish your mom had. I mean that seriously. I agree.. and if you look up spank on the net that is all you see is sick, perverts.. and fetish Galore.. My father in law BEATS his nieces he adopted as his daughters due to deaths.... I protest it when he paddles them all the time especially the 17 year old.. I know its not my place to say anything but who cares.. I think its disgusting for a man to paddle a well endowed senior in high school.. I see and sense other things.. and have voiced it to my husband and his mother... I loath dirty ol men... 

Olivia --- 17 years ago -

both my husband and i were spanked with wooden spoons as kids...and i probably will do the same with my kids. 

Sara --- 17 years ago -

My daughter is 11 months old. She gets wacked on the hand if she's doing something dangerous...like pulling on cords, or playing with the saftey things on the plugs. It doesn't hurt her, cause we don't wack really hard, it more startles her and she normally stays away from them for awhile. We DO NOT, and WILL not smack for dumb things...ie, leaving things laying around that we don't want her to have...thats our fault, not hers...and to a baby, everything is a toy! As for spanking when she gets older, I guess it will depend on the situation, like dangerous things again, otherwise I'm with Nicole. I like the time out system. I was a nanny through school, and it worked like a charm. One warning and those kids were angels. I was spanked tons when I was a kid. With belts, with hands, and I've had pleanty of wooden spoons broken over my a$$. I don't agree with that...and that's a bit close to abuse, but I don't think I turned out any worse for the wear... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground