Are they banned from base? I have all the facts about them. And i swear it won't attack and turn. I know for a fact they won't just attack innocent things for no reason...........
See where this is going....LOL
I'm just being a smart *ss but if you look at the situation this is very simular to those who have pits. You like the animal you want to own it but others are afraid of it and it can be dangerous so that is why they are banning them.
speaking of tigers. my friend had a pit named tiger. meakest, sweetest boy ever. he'd never so much as snapped at anyone. i think he was, 8, 9 years old? i miss tiger.
I'm just being a smart *ss but if you look at the situation this is very simular to those who have pits.
Yeah, it's so not. There is no dog that is equal to a tiger.
Well this brings us back to the demosticated argument. Tigers are NOT demosticated, so there for your argument is void!
Technically, if you want to be logically correct, her argument is valid because YES, it is very similar to the pit bull situation, HOWEVER...since tigers are not domesticated animals like you said that makes her argument unsound.
if you want to be logically correct, her argument is valid because YES, it is very similar to the pit bull situation
I've yet to see the logic in comparing two completely different animals that have zero in common.
I've yet to see the logic in comparing two completely different animals that have zero in common.
that's why it's not a sound argument, like i stated. since tigers are not domesticated animals like you said that makes her argument unsound.
Right, but you said it was logically correct and I don't see it.
I dont know what to tell you, I'm taking logic and it's not an easy topic to explain. I said if you want to be logically correct because it is the correct way to analysis that using logic.
the situation this is very simular
those words used make her argument valid because she gave true premises you cant have a tiger because people are scared of it...they dont have to be the same animal or even remotely the same to be a valid argument. However, it's not a sound argument because their is a chance of a false conclusion because tigers are not domesticated animals---that's the only way i know how to explain it.
I'm taking logic and it's not an easy topic to explain. I said if you want to be logically correct because it is the correct way to analysis that using logic.
But wouldn't logic require you to compare apples to apples? I mean, right now we're comparing apples and a car. It's an argument, sure, but doesn't seem logical.
But wouldn't logic require you to compare apples to apples? I mean, right now we're comparing apples and a car. It's an argument, sure, but doesn't seem logical.
not always, this logic is going beyond what our mind first thinks of as common sense.
Bah... Dogs, cats, rabbits, guinea pig, ferrets, etc...ARE the USUAL pets people have. Tigers are NOT.
Even if tigers were trained or have always been enclosed in a zoo, they are still considered DANGEROUS. Unpredictable & their predator qualities are IMMENSE. How can you compare them to itsy bitsy dogs? :>
the pitbull is looked at the same way it's considered to be dangerous, and many people think it should be locked up or shouldnt even be aloud to be a pet. The reason you can compare it because the pitbull is a particular kind of dog, it's not the whole species we're comparing.
tiger vs. pitbull
people think it would be cool to own one (true for both, not necesssarily everyone but some people)
they have mean and unpredictable qualities (true for both)
people are scared of them (true for both)
These few examples make this a valid argument. Dogs, cats, rabbits, guinea pig, ferrets, etc...ARE the USUAL pets people have. Tigers are NOT.
This statement right here is what makes her argument unsound. It's not a good argument because it's unsound, which means there is a chance of a false conclusion. An unsound argument is never rationally persuasive. The validity and the soundness of an argument are two differnt things, but you can have a valid argument with unsound reasons...such as the one we are discussing.
These few examples make this a valid argument.
Validity isn't logic, though. You can have a valid argument of anything. If two people are disagreeing, technically, that would be a valid argument. To have a logical argument, you should be comparing two like things. So, comparing two animals that are currently domesticated more often than wild, would seem more logical. As someone said before, people are scared of bees and bees can kill. Is it logical to compare a bee to a dog, of any kind? No.
This statement right here is what makes her argument unsound. It's not a good argument because it's unsound, which means there is a chance of a false conclusion. An unsound argument is never rationally persuasive. The validity and the soundness of an argument are two differnt things, but you can have a valid argument with unsound reasons...such as the one we are discussing.
The simplicity of the fact that these pets are EASILY accessible while a tiger ISN'T is already logical. It is not logical to compare an animal that can have MAN EATING attached to its name with dogs. :>
Are they banned from base? I have all the facts about them. And i swear it won't attack and turn. I know for a fact they won't just attack innocent things for no reason...........
Yeah, and I want a 1982 Corvette Stingray. Its not gonna happen. You can crap in one hand and wish in the other an see which one fills up faster.
Validity isn't logic, though. You can have a valid argument of anything. If two people are disagreeing, technically, that would be a valid argument. To have a logical argument, you should be comparing two like things. So, comparing two animals that are currently domesticated more often than wild, would seem more logical. As someone said before, people are scared of bees and bees can kill. Is it logical to compare a bee to a dog, of any kind? No.
yes actually, validity IS part of logic. The main thing i was trying to get at is SaraSassyPants Tigers are NOT demosticated, so there for your argument is void! this is sort of correct, but the word is unsound, not void. Not all arguments are valid. for example, my birthday is may 15,1980 (not really) therefore i am 25 years old. This is both invalid and unsound because there is no way to argue that at all. Her statement is arguable though...so it's valid...that's all valid means, that it is in fact arguable.