Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Would you fight this?

who's talking here?

Paul 2
Nicole 1
Angel 9
All Abouts 1
Bryn~ 1
sToO 1
Victoria 4
SaraSassyPantsII 2
megan85 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Angel --- 16 years ago -

Our couch was damaged in the move, the crates weren't sealed so two of the sections were wet. Rather than risk the mold we decided to just throw them out. We emailed the housing agency and they said they would send out someone to give us an estimate.
Apparently the estimate turned into them just taking it and charging us 11,000 yen.
If we had known it would be that much we would have looked for other options to throw it away. They called my husband and said it was a miscommunication in their office but they still want us to pay it.
WWYD? 

All Abouts --- 16 years ago -

I dont get why would you have to pay for some that was yours in the 1st place and got damaged by the moving ?
However dont we have to keep the damage stuff for 2 yrs , even if the repay us for the damage ? 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

They're charging us for bulk trash pickup. I'm not asking about damage claims. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

Did you sign anything authorizing them to dispose of it? Im not sure how it works here, but if you were just getting an estimate and didnt agree to the "work" then you shouldnt have to pay. Thats their fault for working before authorization.
If they came to do the estimate and then you said ok for them to move it before knowing the amount...then that is your fault and you should pay. 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

Nope we didn't authorize anything. They said they tried to contact us but neither of our phones have missed calls or messages and they didn't email us to pay until after it was done. 

Bryn~ --- 16 years ago -

I'd fight it but that's cause I'm cheap AND there was miscommunication therefore not your fault. 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

You live off base? 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

You live off base?
Yes 

SaraSassyPantsII --- 16 years ago -

You can fight it all you want, but they will still chrage you. It should be in your lease. We signed a paper before we moved in that said bulk trash pick up was 10000 yen. I am pretty sure you signed it too. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

[i]Nope we didn't authorize anything. They said they tried to contact us but neither of our phones have missed calls or messages and they didn't email us to pay until after it was done. [/i]
Hmm id look into your options then. Like I said, I'm not sure how it works here. I know in the states you would not be responsible for it though. That is their fault that they didn't take the time to get authorization first. That said....if you were totally fine with it being gone and didn't say anything about it until you got the bill...then that will look bad. I mean the minute you noticed it gone you should have contacted them to find out what happened. I think it would be easier to get it taken care of if you told them right away that you didn't authorize it.
If you needed it gone though and you can live with the amount it cost, I would just take it as a loss and lesson learned and not hassle with it. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

[i]It should be in your lease. We signed a paper before we moved in that said bulk trash pick up was 10000 yen. I am pretty sure you signed it too. [/i]

Do you live where she lives? How are you pretty sure she signed it too? 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

You can fight it all you want, but they will still chrage you. It should be in your lease. We signed a paper before we moved in that said bulk trash pick up was 10000 yen. I am pretty sure you signed it too.

Actually our lease says trash is included and doesn't mention bulk trash at all.
I didn't sign a damn thing for bulk trash. 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

I mean the minute you noticed it gone you should have contacted them to find out what happened. I think it would be easier to get it taken care of if you told them right away that you didn't authorize it.

Well I was outside at 9am playing with my son and I saw the guy drive by and look at our couch. We went inside about 30 minutes later. Then I got an email at 11 saying they already took it and that we needed to pay. I can't see it from inside my apartment. They didn't give us much time either way. 

SaraSassyPantsII --- 16 years ago -


Do you live where she lives? How are you pretty sure she signed it too?


I am just going off my experiance. We signed a contract saying we would pay for trash, and bulk trash pick up. 

Victoria --- 16 years ago -

[i]Well I was outside at 9am playing with my son and I saw the guy drive by and look at our couch. We went inside about 30 minutes later. Then I got an email at 11 saying they already took it and that we needed to pay. I can't see it from inside my apartment. They didn't give us much time either way. [/i]

Well I would still consider it "right away" then. I just wanted to make sure days hadnt gone by and it wasnt until you got a bill in the mail that yousaid something etc. I would fight it if it is worth it to you...bc I definitely think you dont owe it. 

Nicole --- 16 years ago -

You're likely to be out of luck, but-

first, if you are going to claim damages on your couch through the base, find out if you can claim your bulk trash fee as part of it-since it's required for large items off-base.

second, continue to talk to your agency. You could ask the housing office for help, though you're unlikely to get it. Maybe you can split it with the agency?

Last-even if you didn't sign anything specifically about bulk trash, you likely got papers explaining how to separate your trash-and this paper would note that there is a separate fee for bulk pick up. We got that with both agencies, even though we never signed anything specifically about bulk trash.

Anyways, good luck. 

Paul --- 16 years ago -

You should have held the couch for the company to come back and get it. They should be responsible for the fees. Other than that, you should claim the fees when you file. 

sToO --- 16 years ago -

If anyone is signing a paper authorizing a 10,000yen charge each time you have a bulk trash pickup, ... WHY are you signing something like that?!
If it is part of the lease, and it was reviewed (as required) by the KAB Housing Office, then I would go back to them to make sure that is legal.
If it is NOT part of the lease, then why would you sign anything like that?!!
You should take ALL your paperwork from the rental housing agency to the KAB office to review.

Bulk trash falls under many categories.
But to charge 10000yen for each pickup is robbery.

If you CLEARLY asked the agency for an ESTIMATE, and then when it was quickly picked up is their mistake.

you could probably contact one of those delivery guys on OYS who have a truck and had them haul it away to the dump (near Kurashiki Dam past the SE botanical gardens). it would probably be 2000 or 3000 yen max to dispose of it.
You can fill one of those small papasan white trucks with trash and it costs less than 2000yen for the whole truckload to be dumped there. (it all goes by weight and big stuff is extra).

If the agency did not give you an estimate via email as you requested, then they are at fault for just hauling it and charging you. 

megan85 --- 16 years ago -

So I live off-base too and actually got up to look at the copy of my contract. It doesn't say anything about Bulk trash. But I'm pretty sure if we needed to have a couch picked up they would charge. I would argue especially since they said it was a misunderstanding on their side. 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

I looked though all of our paperwork this afternoon and we do have a paper that talks about how to throw out your garbage but for bulk items it says to call the number at the bottom for instruction....but then the number at the bottom was blocked out, and it's just a flyer, no signatures or anything.

I emailed them after they called my husband again. I told them we will only talk to them in writing and that we want to negotiate this with them. 

megan85 --- 16 years ago -

I hope it all works out and that ur not stuck paying for their mistake. What housing agency do u have? 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

We have seaside. 

megan85 --- 16 years ago -

ohhh we have Robinson and they are amazing!! 

Angel --- 16 years ago -

Well they agreed to pay for half of it, which we were fine with, but then we noticed that our stroller was missing as well. So I asked them if they threw away our stroller too and they did, so now they're paying for all of it.
I have no idea WHY they thought our stroller was garbage too, it was on the other side of the garage by a cooler and some beach chairs. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground