Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Unions.

who's talking here?

The Gunny 2
ChiTownGrl 3
Casey 5
The Dramallama 2
yourmomdotcom 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Casey --- 15 years ago -

mom sent me an article this morning. considering all the crap with teachers unions and whatnot, what are your thoughts?

Unions 

The Gunny --- 15 years ago -

I think that having unions is like a double-edged sword. On one hand, they are necessary to ensure that businesses don’t take advantage of their employees. I also think that at times, the unions have a strangle hold on the companies and force the hand of the employers that they work for.

A couple of years ago, I made an anti-union comment to my brother (who is a professional union negotiator and chief steward for the union at the company he works for) and he wouldn’t talk to me for months. He was telling me that he was representing a man that had wrecked a company vehicle 3 times in the last nine months and that the company had sent him home without pay for a week. My position was that the man should be fired. I mean, who wrecks their own vehicle that many times? Not many people do; they only do when it’s not their vehicle and they are careless. His position was that the company had no right to send him home with or without pay because they had not consulted the union. In the end, the man got his week off…..WITH pay because of the union grievance that was filed. Who is running the company….the owners or the workers?

I think that unions should be more closely regulated but that would take money and other resources that our government just doesn’t have. It would also cost the taxpayers and it’s just not something I’m willing to pay for. It’d be easy to just say disband unions and let workers and companies sink or swim but I don’t think that is the answer either. I guess this post is just a long way of me saying….I just don’t know! Lol

That being said, I think that President Obama said something the other day that is one of the smartest things he has ever said. When asked about whether the government was going to intervene in the NFL union problem he simply said…”I think that a company that creates over $9 billion in revenue can figure it out for themselves”. 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

Definitely a difference between private and public Unions. Just for SA- there are now more people in Public Unions than private.

I think Unions are good but should be limited. It's one of the reasons some American products are so expensive and therefore can't compete as well with similar products made in other countries. It's also one of the reasons many employers and large businesses have fled the U.S... or gone to "right to work" states

Public Unions have the same problem. Public employees need to understand that budgets are not infinite and can't sustain some of the pay, benefits and pensions previously negotiated- especially at the state and local level. Not saying that public employees aren't necessary or undeserving- but no one made them become public employees. They did that all on their own. And they are free to move on just like anybody else who thinks they can get more for their talents elsewhere. 

The Gunny --- 15 years ago -

KIR....well put ^ 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

On one hand, they are necessary to ensure that businesses don’t take advantage of their employees

This I disagree with. Plenty of people go to work everyday without being represented by a union and they aren't taken advantage of.

I do agree that they are a double edged sword. For the union workers, a union is great when there is work. When there is no work, not so much. My uncle is a union electrician and they haven't had work in almost a year and there is no work in the foreseeable future. They aren't allowed to work for anyone else, so I'm unsure how they are expected to pay their bills.

I see no advantage to unions for those that aren't in them. As KIR said, public unions cost the government tons of money. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

This I disagree with. Plenty of people go to work everyday without being represented by a union and they aren't taken advantage of.

i think this type of good business practice has developed because there's now recourse for treating people poorly. people can sue the business/company that put them in poor working conditions. it used to be different, and that would be why unions were formed in the first place.

i once mentioned in passing while i was sitting at my friend's dad's union shop waiting for her... that my dad drives a snow plow in the winter. it was the first year he'd done it, and i didn't pay much mind to who my dad hangs out with at the time, so i was a little confused when her dad asked whether he drove a plow for the city, or for a private business-because he'd never heard of him before. i just said "well, i don't know. i think he works for his friend bill... i'm not sure beyond that."

he proceeded to yell-lecture me about how if he was working for the city and not in the union he had better watch his @ss.

i went home and told my dad... he just shook his head and laughed. dad works for a friends private plow business, but he thought it was amusing i got a lecture at all, since i was the 16 year old daughter, not the guy who "better watch his @ss!" 

The Dramallama --- 15 years ago -

Union's were probably a useful thing back when there were few labor laws. Now that everything is regulated so heavily they are just a dying breed attempting to cling to the good ol' boys club. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I agree DL. They are outdated and no longer necessary. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

i agree for the most part too. although when someone is really wronged by a company, unions are pretty helpful with the legal assistance and ensuring it doesn't happen again. 

The Dramallama --- 15 years ago -

Please dont ever tell my grandpa i wrote that, he is a dyed in the wool sheetmetal worker and would disown me for it :P 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

yea, same with a lot of my family... grandpa worked the mines before there were unions... not that he cares now that he's gone. but that might piss off my grandmother who worked in every kitchen at every mine he worked too. 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

Both of my parents owned their own small businesses so I was never really exposed to unions. Even when I worked for a large corporation before the Corps never really heard about unions. My parents businesses although successful were never large enough to be exposed to any union activities.

I do think that there are certainly large private corporations that could potentially abuse their position as employers. On the other hand for the most part there are enough laws that allow for redress of any issues. Also with few exceptions (law enforcement for example) I see little need for unions for public or govt employees. One of the big problems I have with unions is their politics. Your union dues could be going to support a candidate that you don't agree with. I don't think unions should be allowed to donate to campaigns- too much conflict of interest IMO. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

Your union dues could be going to support a candidate that you don't agree with. I don't think unions should be allowed to donate to campaigns- too much conflict of interest IMO. 

And they get told who to vote for. Nobody will ever know how they vote, obviously, but many unions tell their members they must vote for a certain person. 

yourmomdotcom --- 15 years ago -

There are exceptions to every rule but the vast majority of unions support only one particular party. And in many states you arent given the option of whether you want to join a union or not. I believe there are only 20 or so right to work states. I personally don't think you should have to join a union just to work somewhere. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

i did have to join the union to work at the nursing home i did, but we didn't vote for a specific candidate or contribute campaign funds. the only voting we did was for president of the union, neither person i'd ever met before. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground