Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

remember...

who's talking here?

ChiTownGrl 3
Casey 7
The Dramallama 1
Proud Army Wife 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Casey --- 15 years ago -

the mom with the hot sauce? the parents on supernanny i am watching right now use it too. i remember wishing the mom from dr. phil had gone to super nanny instead, we'll see what she says about it. 

The Dramallama --- 15 years ago -

Well? 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

i didn't get back on here.

she was not pleased... but didn't define it as abuse. she said it's obvious it's not working, so stop it. they spanked the kids and threatened to spank with a wooden spoon too. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

lol yea. if super nanny doesn't realy think it's abuse, it's probably not. she said that what they were doing was not working, and pointed out "what are you going to do when the dab of hot sauce doesn't work anymore? use the whole bottle? and what about when spanking doesn't hurt anymore, hit them harder? and what about when they're big enough to smack you back? then what?"

basically.. she said don't do it anymore, because it will escalate. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

she didn't say no spankings for anyone, she meant it wasn't working for this family. dad was REALLY quick to just turn around and woop the kid before even teaching them not to do things. no warning except a spanking. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

Super Nanny's reasoning doesn't make any sense. She gives kids time outs over and over again. According to what she said about spanking, if you have to keep doing it, it's not working. I think Super Nanny is full of crap. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

well, with time out it goes by age, and it's the same standard punishment.

what she was pointing out with the other physical disciplines was that eventually, they get used to the amount of force you use, and you're going to have to do it harder until it's going to get to where it's either not affecting them no matter how hard, or it becomes harmful.

i don't see how sitting them in time out until they've served their time is going to become physically harmful. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

i know lots of kids that have. my little nephew will turn around after his dad has wooped him one and his hand is sore, and he'll go " NAH NAH THAT DIDN'T HURT!!! ahahahaha!"

he doesn't get spanked anymore. :| 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

well, again, she was tailoring her method for this specific family. 

Proud Army Wife --- 15 years ago -

I spank my child. He's only been spanked a few times- but he now knows when I start counting to three, that he had best stop what he's doing. He's only 2 and has learned it fabulously. 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I agree with M. Super Nanny doesn't believe in corporal punishment in any form, so she will never advise it, no matter what the family's situation is. Every family and every child are different. To say something is completely out of question is closed minded and to assume that spanking your kid is going to escalate into beating the crap out of them is ridiculous. Does it happen in some families? I'm sure it does, but I highly doubt that abusive parents all started out by giving a little swat on the butt.

well, with time out it goes by age, and it's the same standard punishment.


It only goes up by a minute each year. I'm sure in the course of a year a kid gets enough time outs to become used to that amount of time. What age do you stop giving time outs? What if grounding and taking away privileges don't work? Not all kids are the same. 

Proud Army Wife --- 15 years ago -

What if grounding and taking away privileges don't work? Not all kids are the same.





I liked what someone said in another thread before- just make them do PT things- like wall sits and stuff...

If that were me. I'd be like I'll never be bad again... :D 

ChiTownGrl --- 15 years ago -

I agree. I will never say "I would never do that" or judge other parents for how they punish (unless it's obvious physical abuse) because you never know how long certain punishments will work. My daughter is only 17 months and we've had to change our form of punishment several times already. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground