Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Potatoe salad recipe

who's talking here?

heather 1
Balls To The Wall 3
Loved living in Oki 2
Nicole 4
JessicaB 6
Elizabeth 2
JennaDoll 1
Amurikan Lunatic 2
xiaojun 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

ok ladies I have NEVER made this before and was asked to do so today for this weekend...

one, how hard is this going to be?

two, any advice on where to find the most yummy recipe?

Thanks in advance! 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

ok you are going to laugh at me should I peel the taters first before boiling them? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Up to you. I peel, cut and then boil. If you get the red potatoes, I like to leave the peel on those and then eat with peel.

Some people boil in the peel and then remove it. It comes off easier that way. 

Amurikan Lunatic --- 15 years ago -

Isn't there mustard in potato salad? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

^ usually.

Some people use Miracle Whip too instead of mayo, but that's yuck. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

I love Miracle Whip. 

Amurikan Lunatic --- 15 years ago -

I ate at a restaurant in Hawaii that had a potato/macaroni salad hybrid. It was flipping awesome. 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

Thanks ladies, like I said I have never made it before so I knew you wonderful's could help me out...I hate miracle whip also...I was thinking of mustard but didn't know how that would turn out... 

Balls To The Wall --- 15 years ago -

I use red potatoes.

Mayo, boiled eggs, sweet relish, celery seed, and a little dry mustard. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Coco's has a good potato salad. 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

How long should I boil the patotoes for? 

Balls To The Wall --- 15 years ago -

Sometimes I add red bell pepper. I like my food to be colorful. 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

Red bell pepper sounds yummy, does anyone add celery? or am I thinking of something else? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

My SIL adds finely chopped radish. It's really good that way. I've not seen radishes here before though. :( 

Balls To The Wall --- 15 years ago -

I just bought radishes at Foster. 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

Make sure not to over cook the potatoes. I did one time and it all turned to mush. Ended up with mashed potatoes instead of potatoe salad!! 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I just bought radishes at Foster.

Really? 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

do you take the middle part out of the egg and just use the white parts? I know I know I'm a mess LOL but I'm off to the commissary to get the stuff then making it tonight for tomorrow or should I make it tomorrow???? 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

I use the whole egg (white and yellow). I also put pickles, celery, mustard & mayo. If your going to use mustard make sure to slowly add it as your mixing. You don't want too much mustard. More mayo than mustard.

I like my potatoe salad a little warm (so right after I mix and make it) but some people like it cold. Depends on what you like. You can make it tonight to get it out of the way and put it in the fridge. Either way it will be good. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Best potato salad recipe EVER:

Ina's Potato Salad

I always make mine at least 24 hours ahead, so it has time to set the flavors through. 

JennaDoll --- 15 years ago -

I just bought radishes at Foster.

Really?



I go there to buy them too. My husband eats them like apple. EWWWW. 

xiaojun --- 10 years ago -

This comment has been flagged as spam 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground