Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Highback booster seat vs Backless

who's talking here?

heather 12
Loved living in Oki 5
Nicole 10
dependopotamus 11
**Ashley** 3
♥Mrs. Boss ♥ 6
Angel 1
FkYouPanda 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

**Ashley** --- 15 years ago -

What is your opinion and which do you prefer? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Highback booster only if they are too big to still fit a 5pt harness.

I think the highback is preferable because it offers a belt path route (to keep the belt in the definite right spot) and offers protection to the head. 

Angel --- 15 years ago -

Highback does a better job of keeping kids in the proper place if they fall asleep, they've also been proven to provide more protection than a backless in a side impact collision.

Though I'm hoping my short child will be 5 pt harnessed for a very long time. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Though I'm hoping my short child will be 5 pt harnessed for a very long time.

Lots of car seats are made now to allow for this. :)

My almost 5 year old is still 5pt harnessed (and he's not small) and he's still got one more harness slot and about 23 more pounds before he outgrows his 5pt. 

FkYouPanda --- 15 years ago -

I never used booster seats for my little ones so I can't say.

But I'd guess high back seems better. 

**Ashley** --- 15 years ago -

Uh, no. I have two kids. Thanks though:) 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Here Ashley, look at this comparison.  

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

So sorry for not keeping up with the details of your life

I think you need more sleep, grumpy. 

**Ashley** --- 15 years ago -

Thanks Nicole! I like the highback but was not sure how it would be in the backseat with our car in the states. I think it will work. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

If those were my only two options, I would chose the high-backed. However, Britax makes a 5-point carseat big enough to fit a child up to seven years old or 80 lbs. My almost six year old is still comfortably in a 5-point. 

dependopotamus --- 15 years ago -

My almost six year old is still comfortably in a 5-point. 

Does he still suck on a pacifier too?
Thats strange to think that you snap your almost 6 year old in to a car seat. We used a booster seat as soon as our son turned 4.. It was a high back one...
Then when we came here we left it behind in the states with my brother there would be no need for it.. He is almost as tall as i am and he's 7.. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Does he still suck on a pacifier too?

No. Keeping a child in a seat within the age/height/weight limits of said seat doesn't infantilize that child anymore than taking him out of the seat while still in the limits causes him to mature too fast. It's just a chair. Your way is just *a* way of doing things, not the *right* way just like the way I chose is just *a* way. A way that I am not alone in mentioning in this thread. But thank you for the judgmental condescending attitude, I can see how you would think it was necessary to get your point across. 

♥Mrs. Boss ♥ --- 15 years ago -

My kid is 11 and only weighs 71 lbs...Think she should still be in a carseat cause she will fit the weight class?

She is dang near as tall as I am also.....I feel she is safe sitting in the backseat buckled up with the seatbelt. If the seatbelt fits them comfortably and correctly I do not think they need to be in a carseat anymore. ( especially once they hit a certain age. :-)

I also have to add that she is allowed to be in the front seat according to security forces. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Uuhhh, did I say something wrong here or are some of you on crack?? Your kid is ELEVEN. She is also YOUR KID. It's up to you to determine whether or not her seat belt fits. Car seat, seat belt, put her in the d*mn trunk for all I care. I don't *think* one way or another about what you do with your kid. I didn't say that 11 year olds should be in a car seat. I didn't even say that a 5 year old *should* be. I said mine is... that's it. No judgments, no implications, no undertones, nothing. 

dependopotamus --- 15 years ago -

Keeping children in rear-facing car seats until at least age 2, or until they meet the height and weight limits set for the seat.

• Using booster seats for children over age 4 but who haven't yet grown to 4 feet 9 inches tall.(phew i barely make this cut off..)

• Keeping kids in the back seat until they're at least 13 years old.

Heather no one is saying your parenting style is any different i just found it strange that your almost 6 year old is riding in a CAR SEAT with a five point harness VS a high back Booster seat.Yes yes I am on Crack but its for weight loss purpose only don't judge. 

dependopotamus --- 15 years ago -

:) 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Ok, I think maybe some of us are confusing what is a high-back booster vs a forward-facing 5-point car seat. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Booster:

http://carseatblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/cosco-complete-voyager-booster.jpg

Car seat:

http://static.howstuffworks.com/gif/productImages/6/8/00000118768-Safety1stSummitDeluxeHighBackBoosterCarSeat22565-large.jpeg 

heather --- 15 years ago -

You have to copy and paste the link into your browser. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Booster 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Car Seat 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

My almost 5 year old will be sitting in his 5pt as long as it accomodates him. And, I haven't ruled out buying yet another one with higher weight limits in the future. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Heather no one is saying your parenting style is any different

I didn't think anyone had said that. You reacted to my post as if I had insulted everyone whose child isn't riding around in a 5-point until they are 17. My use of a 5-point (and therefore my mentioning it) wasn't a slam against those who don't. I could understand your reaction and that of Mrs. Boss, if I had been condescending... if I had said something like "How dare you even consider using a booster you malodorous nincompoop!" but I didn't. I even double-checked my post to make sure and no. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I highly recommend anyone returning stateside keep their child in that 5pt as long as possible. Speeds are so much higher there and accidents so much worse. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Does crack help you lose weight? If so, which of you has some that I could get? 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Where are you planning to lose weight from? 

I never did lose those five pounds you told me I should lose. 

♥Mrs. Boss ♥ --- 15 years ago -

Heather....sarcasm is not your strong point is it? I was being sarcastic in regards to this comment that you had made below.....hence the reason I said my daughter is 11 and weighs 71 lbs ....there for she fits in this carseat you are referring to.......




Britax makes a 5-point carseat big enough to fit a child up to seven years old or 80 lbs. My almost six year old is still comfortably in a 5-point.  

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

You've been hiding it well. 

I suck in a lot. It's really tiring. 

dependopotamus --- 15 years ago -

Shhhhh don't tell LLIo where she can score some weight loss her husband is the fuzz... 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Mrs Boss, if sarcasm isn't my strong suit, then reading isn't yours.

Britax makes a 5-point carseat big enough to fit a child up to seven years old or 80 lbs. My almost six year old is still comfortably in a 5-point.

up to seven years old or 80 lbs.

seven years old 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground