Okinawa Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Okinawa bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Okinawa housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

food dyes

who's talking here?

Loved living in Oki 5
Nicole 13
Casey 1
dependopotamus 1
JessicaB 2
sToO 2
Amurikan Lunatic 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

For discussion.

Should food dyes be banned?

I'll go first. I say yes. Regardless of whether or not they play a part in hyperactivity, they aren't necessary. Major manufacturers are not allowed to put some of these dyes in foods sold in Europe, so why can't they change the US food??

For example, Nutri-Grain bars. In England, they cannot have red dye, so they don't. Yet, here, they are loaded. 

dependopotamus --- 15 years ago -

American people don't care enough to not put it in foods? We buy things on instinct of color.If its bland and ugly we won't want to buy it. so they put color in to associate with taste of the product. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

There are non-artificial colorings that can be used instead. 

Amurikan Lunatic --- 15 years ago -

Are they dangerous? If not, then what's the harm. If they are, then absolutely they need to be banned. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I think it's up for debate about the ramifications of them. But if they aren't necessary, why have them? We try as hard as we can to avoid food with artificial dyes, but it's really hard. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

I just eat what tastes good. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Why not just grab an apple, peanut butter that's just peanuts and naturally occuring oils, and a good bread that's actually bread instead of stuff with a bunch of non-baking essential crap added? You'd actually get more nutrients.

Very true. I try to eat as little processed as possible, but I do buy things like granola bars (Kashi ones though-try to go as healthful as possible with that stuff) for on the go-especially for my kids. 

Amurikan Lunatic --- 15 years ago -

I just think, why have to make another rule. Just don't buy it. Seems as if we keep adding rules and regulations for the hell of it. 

sToO --- 15 years ago -

There are non-artificial colorings that can be used instead.

The companies would probably raise prices since that would be more expensive to use non-artificial stuff. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Just don't buy it.

That's very difficult to do actually. The dyes are quite ubiquitous. They are in things you've never even think of-not just brightly colored (and obvious artificially) colored things.

Pastas, jam, marshmallows, crackers, some breads, etc. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I'm not like, snapping at you about the whole granola bar thing.

No, I didn't think you were. :)

Sliced washed fruits are perfect for me-not so perfect for an on the go snack for a 2 year old. lol 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I'm not a parent. Why?

The mess factor. Sticky, juicy fruit. 2 year olds can make a mess of anything. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

I just had Taco Bell. Yum. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Are fruit/veggies just like a tragedy compared to like, a granola bar?

Granola bar crumbs mostly brush off.

We do a lot of fruit as snacks. I'm pretty lucky. My kids love stuff like plain yogurt and fruit. I don't often get complaints about not buying stuff in the snack aisle. Once in awhile as a treat we'll get something. 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

Has anyone seen food inked? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Has anyone seen food inked?

??

What is this? 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

You go down the snack aisle?

Once in awhile.

I do produce, meat, baking aisle, sometimes pasta and brown rice, then head to the baby aisle sometimes, then cleaning, and then cold stuff.

We sometimes buy pretzels and such. And I go down the soda aisle to buy water filters.

I do go down the cereal aisle often though, so we can buy oatmeal. :) 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -


I'm going to venture a guess that marshmallows are bad for you with or without dye.


Yes, yes they are. But why add even more crap to it?

Or for example-the motrin that we are given for the kids. It's full of dyes. WHY? Who cares what color it is? I have to have my mom send dye-free stuff to me. Toothpaste too. I have that sent. And shampoo. And.... 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

I'm going to venture a guess that marshmallows are bad for you with or without dye. 

NNOOOO!!!! I'm making s'mores this weekend! 

sToO --- 15 years ago -

First sentence of that linked article is:
"Some evidence links dyes found in everyday foods to hyperactivity in certain children"

Some evidence links ______ found in everyday foods to hyperactivity in certain children.
You can fill in the blank with many ingredients, there are many to choose from.

There is probably a study somewhere on nearly everything saying it causes problems. There is also another study on the same stuff saying it does not cause problems. One of my doctor friends back in USA reads and reviews many studies like these. When people find out what his job is that ask him what is safe or unsafe to eat. He jokingly (but seriously) answers, “Anything, everything but possibly nothing”.

A key word in that sentence is "certain". Meaning not all, just some, maybe 'few' children are possibly affected by these dyes. All this fuss for just a few kids?
The article also uses the description "certain susceptible children".
Well, some certain susceptible children are allergic to peanuts, or gluten, etc. Should all foods be free of every ingredient that might possible cause some sort of thingy/condition in some/few/certain children?



In support of my first comment about increased prices ----
Does anyone remember learning about Red Dye No. 2 and the scare about it being a carcinogen? It was used for decades in many foods. When it was finally banned by the FDA, companies switched to a new dye (No. 40), and food prices went up.

From TIME article Feb 1976:
“The ruling may push up the price of many consumer products. Red No. 40 costs $8.50 per lb., v. $5.50 for No. 2, and manufacturers have to use 30% to 50% more of it to get the same color intensity as with Red No. 2. Even then, the colors do not come out quite the same.” 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Nope. I'm more interested in flavor. And I'm using Reese's Cups. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

Meaning not all, just some, maybe 'few' children are possibly affected by these dyes. All this fuss for just a few kids?

I usually tend to agree with statements like that, but these are artificial dyes that aren't necessary.

The strawberry jam I buy without the dye looks just as red as the jam with it.... 

JessicaB --- 15 years ago -

Everyone should watch the movie food inc!

http://www.foodincmovie.com/ 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Those aren't smores.

They're better than s'mores. 

Casey --- 15 years ago -

i watched food inc. twice. part of health class actually.. still find my over dyed, pretty colored foods delicious. meh. 

Nicole --- 15 years ago -

I've never even heard of food inc. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Okinawa Underground